TLDR Critique of UI designs, emphasizing practical skills for production readiness. Evaluation of almost hirable designs with suggestions for improvement.

Key insights

  • ⚖️ Evaluating real designers' work for hirability amidst industry challenges, without negativity, for self-assessment.
  • 👨‍🎨 Critique of UI designs focusing on practical skills for product development over portfolio aesthetics.
  • 🎨 Suggestions for usability improvements, color palette considerations, and maintaining a balance between creativity and usability.
  • 📊 Evaluation of UI designs for production readiness, assessment based on key criteria, and rating designs accordingly.
  • 🌈 Strategic use of color and avatars to enhance user experience, clear iconography, and distinctive design.
  • ⚙️ Incorporation of customized elements, experimental yet functional approach, and desirability of the design work.

Q&A

  • What are the key elements of the UI designs praised in the video?

    The praised UI designs are characterized as modern, unique, and playful, incorporating customized elements like graphs, imagery, and a cool style. They are experimental yet functional, with strategic use of color and avatars to enhance the user experience, featuring good navigation, clear iconography, and a mature, distinctive design.

  • What suggestions are provided for improving UI designs?

    Suggestions include usability improvements, considerations for color palette and brand consistency, maintaining a balance between creativity and usability, and strategic use of color and avatars to enhance user experience. Additionally, the evaluation criteria consist of space utilization, navigation, imagery, and color usage to determine hirability.

  • What are the critiques of the UI designs discussed in the video?

    The critiques include issues with empty spaces, excessive drop shadows, lack of usability and accessibility due to unlabeled elements, confusing navigation, unnecessary animations, and design elements resembling a 'garage sale.' Emphasis is placed on the need for practical skills for product development and revenue growth over portfolio aesthetics.

  • What is the video about?

    The video discusses the challenges and evaluations of UI designs in the creative industry, particularly focusing on dark-themed dashboards and the emphasis on practical skills over portfolio aesthetics for hirability.

  • 00:00 Tough time in creative industry, companies laying off, few hiring UI designers. Evaluating real designers' work for hirability. Not here to hate, for self-assessment. Reviewing dark themed dashboard, immature design decisions, inconsistencies, lack of labels and iconography, difficulty with dark theme.
  • 01:55 Critiques on UI designs lacking usability and feasibility for production, emphasis on needing practical skills for product development over portfolio aesthetics.
  • 03:56 Critique of user interface designs with examples of almost hirable but not fully polished designs. Suggestions include usability improvements, color palette considerations, and maintaining a balance between creativity and usability.
  • 06:09 A designer critiques various UI designs, evaluating their suitability for production, especially focusing on the use of space, navigation, imagery, and color. He assesses designs as almost hirable, hirable, or completely hirable based on these criteria.
  • 08:07 Design elements like avatars and color are used strategically to enhance user experience. The interface features good navigation, clear iconography, and mature, distinctive design.
  • 10:21 The UI design is modern, unique, and playful, incorporating customized elements such as graphs, imagery, and a cool style. It is experimental yet functional, making it very desirable and hirable.

Evaluating UI Design Hirability: Practicality Over Aesthetics

Summaries → Education → Evaluating UI Design Hirability: Practicality Over Aesthetics