Key insights

• ⚙️ Peer assessment encompasses higher order concerns such as structure and evidence, not just grammar and punctuation
• 🎯 Focusing on the purpose of writing and big picture ideas is vital during peer assessment
• 🔍 Constructive criticism should be provided in peer reviews instead of generic feedback
• ⚖️ Balancing positive and critical feedback is crucial in peer assessment
• 📚 Encouraging students to take peer assessment seriously and use available resources

Q&A

• How can students be encouraged to take peer assessment seriously?

  Students can be encouraged to take peer assessment seriously by emphasizing the importance of constructive feedback, asking questions related to the feedback given, and promoting the use of resources such as the writing center for help and assistance.

• What are some key strategies for effective peer assessment?

  Key strategies for effective peer assessment include reading through the entire essay before providing feedback, asking questions to open a dialogue and encourage critical thinking, reviewing the paper multiple times to focus on different concerns, and offering overall comments and suggestions for improvement at the end of the essay.

• Why is it important to provide constructive feedback in peer assessment?

  Providing constructive feedback is important in peer assessment as it encourages improvement in writing, prompts critical thinking, opens a dialogue among peers, and helps in overall enhancement of writing skills.

• How should feedback be provided in peer assessment?

  Feedback in peer assessment should be constructive, with a balance of positive and critical comments. It should prompt classmates to improve their writing, encourage critical thinking, and include specific suggestions for enhancement.

• What should peer assessment focus on?

  Peer assessment should focus on higher order concerns such as structure, argument, evidence, and the purpose of writing. It goes beyond checking grammar and punctuation.

• 00:01 Peer assessment involves more than checking for grammar and punctuation. It includes reviewing higher order concerns such as structure, argument, and evidence. Reading through the entire essay before providing feedback is crucial for a comprehensive assessment.
• 01:41 Peer assessment should focus on the purpose of writing and big picture ideas rather than grammar, and asking questions in feedback can benefit both the writer and the reviewer.
• 03:13 Give constructive criticism in peer reviews and avoid generic feedback like 'everything looks good'. There is always room for improvement in writing, so it's important to provide helpful suggestions for enhancement.
• 04:36 Provide constructive feedback when assessing essays to prompt classmates to improve their writing. Consider asking questions to open a dialogue and encourage critical thinking. Include positive feedback as well as constructive criticism.
• 06:01 Providing constructive feedback involves balancing positive and critical comments. It's important to review the paper multiple times, focusing on different concerns each time. Offer overall comments and suggestions for improvement at the end of the essay.
• 07:27 Encouraging students to take peer assessment seriously and provide constructive feedback, emphasizing the importance of asking questions, and promoting the use of resources like the writing center for help.